6 Comments
User's avatar
Mzwakhe's avatar

His obsession with fertility is actually a mark of seriousness. If we assume Russia will continue to have its current ambitions and the military will continue to operate the way it does, fertility should be treated with deadly seriousness. Its unfortunate that such a terrible person is treating the fertility crisis with an urgency lacking in most democratic governments. I doubt cracking down on abortion will turn the tide but then again nobody has figured out how to deal with this issue.

Maxim Tovkaylo's avatar

Besides banning abortion ads, the Russian authorities are doing a lot to boost the birth rate. Subsidizing mortgage interest, giving big one-time payments for having a child, supporting female students who decide to become moms, etc. Together with ongoing pro-baby propaganda, these steps could start showing results in a few years.

Mzwakhe's avatar

Thank you for telling me this, I had no idea. That being said I'm skeptical about the effect this will have. Even the most generous welfare states going the extra mile to accommodate and help mothers has barely moved the fertility dial. As far as I know Israel is the only developed country with a tfr close to 3 and that seems to largely be down to the ultraorthodox having so many kids and fostering a child having culture. Being non-religious I'm disappointed by the failure of secular projects to raise fertility but I have yet to see a successful fertility raising project.

Abhcán's avatar

If Putin was actually a serious and competent leader, he could stop his meat grinder of a war. That would have the benefits of not wasting Russian lives, of removing uncertainty that has depressed birth rates, of not encouraging flight of Russians abroad, and of not wasting money that could be used to encourage birth rates.

Mzwakhe's avatar

I completely agree, but if I take his desire to conquer Ukraine as a given and as a terrible but persistent feature of Kremlin elites and leaders (both historically and currently) I can also conclude a focus on fertility makes sense.

Russian fertility and fertility in almost every country (particularly developed countries) has been on a persistent downward trajectory. This trend started before the war and will continue long after it has concluded. I do not doubt that the war contributes to fertility but the fundamental driver of the fertility crash isn't the war. The US, Denmark, Germany, France, South Korea, etc all have low fertility and it is proving an insoluble problem (although Dr Alice Evans, Lyman Stone and other such people are starting to map the contours of the problem). Very few of those countries have leadership that is seriously wrestling with the issue (South Korea declared it a nation emergency but the steps they have taken give the lie to that declaration) and Putin, despite being a horrible person is focused on it with an unusual seriousness.

John Quiggin's avatar

I was struck by the decline in Russian domestic car sales, given that European competitors have left and Chinese imports are restricted. What is the role of sanctions here? I read early on in the war that various features had to be stripped out as parts were sanctioned. But three years in, and with no end in sight, you would think that buyers would have little choice but to buy even second-rate cars. My inference (consistent with the high level of interest rates) is that inflation is actually higher than reported, and the purchasing power of wages correspondingly lower.